Top Strategies for Trophy Hunting in MLB The Show 26

DarkTigerX

In MLB The Show 26, earning the Platinum trophy is a thrilling achievement that requires dedication across multiple game modes. Fortunately, the trophy list is relatively compact and avoids excessive online grinding, meaning you can earn 100% completion with a bit of planning. Here’s a breakdown of the best strategies for hunting down all the trophies in this year’s game.

Core Trophy Strategies

Road to the Show (RTTS) Milestones:

1 In Your Heart
To get drafted as the #1 overall pick, you’ll need to perform exceptionally well during high school and the combine. Make sure to excel in key drills and showcase your skills in front of scouts to maximize your draft stock.

Moving Up the Board
If you want a bit of a challenge, opt for college before entering the draft. This will give you extra opportunities to boost your stats, improving your chances of being drafted higher.

Going Gold
In RTTS, you’ll have the chance to complete various mini-games. To earn the ‘Going Gold’ trophy, choose a joystick-based mini-game like the ball recognition drill. If you complete it with a gold medal, the trophy is yours.

Suit Up
This is a simple but fun one—equip your RTTS player with gear in every equipment slot. This trophy requires you to deck out your player from head to toe.

I Don’t Need It
Accumulate 50 Show Tokens and hold onto them in your inventory. This trophy encourages a little patience, as Show Tokens are earned through gameplay and missions.

Diamond Dynasty & Storylines:

Gone Questing
In Diamond Dynasty, successfully complete a full Diamond Quest map run to unlock this trophy. Focus on defeating mini-bosses to earn XP and valuable rewards to progress.

Flush
While working through Diamond Quest, save your Peanuts (currency) to buy two perks from the Coach’s Cart on a single map. Aim for around 3,000 Peanuts to afford high-tier perks that can make your journey smoother.

NLB Historian '26
To earn this trophy, complete four Negro League Storylines. These storylines will help you unlock valuable content while diving deep into the history of baseball.

Gameplay & Skill Challenges:

GOAT MODE
This trophy requires you to temporarily raise the difficulty to GOAT and record a single hit or strikeout. You can earn this trophy in any offline game mode, making it a flexible and relatively easy one to unlock.

Rally Trophies
Enter an inning while losing and trigger a sequence of trophies by getting hits. Start with "The Start of Something" (3 hits), followed by "Don’t Call it a Rally" (5 hits), and finally, "Rally Cap" (7 hits).

Situational Plays:

A Robbery!
One of the more exciting trophies, you’ll need to rob a home run at the wall. It’s a high-skill challenge that requires precise timing and positioning in the outfield.

Down Low… Too Slow
Perform a swim move to avoid a tag while sliding into a base. This trophy emphasizes your ability to make quick, tactical moves when the pressure is on.

THE SHOW 2-6
For this one, you need to record a 2-6 putout (catcher to shortstop) during a game. It’s a specific but fun trophy to unlock if you focus on getting your players in the right positions during defensive plays.

Efficiency Tips for Platinum

Difficulty Tweak
For situational hitting trophies like the 7-hit rally, try playing on Rookie difficulty as the home team. You can intentionally walk four hitters to fall behind and then "tee off" in the bottom half to complete the challenge quickly.

Franchise Cleanup
To grab the "Horses in the Pen" trophy, set up an opening pitcher for a bullpen game in Franchise mode. This will allow you to efficiently earn the trophy without much hassle.

Misc. Quick Gains
Some trophies are incredibly easy to earn and can be completed in your very first game. For example, "Swing Batter Batter" (first swing) and "Are You Still There?" (striking out looking) are simple trophies that you’ll earn naturally as you get into the game.

Trophy hunting in MLB The Show 26 is a rewarding challenge, especially with the game’s diverse modes. With a bit of planning, you can efficiently complete the majority of the trophies. Whether you’re grinding in RTTS, completing Diamond Dynasty quests, or nailing situational plays, there’s plenty of fun to be had as you chase the coveted Platinum trophy.